Unhelpful Criticism | Dependent Origination

Developing Constructive Feedback and Support with the Twelve Nidanas of Dependent Origination

Lets use the example of unhelpful criticism to illustrate the Twelve Nidanas of dependent origination.
1. Ignorance (avijja): The person lacks understanding of the true nature of reality, including the interconnectedness of all phenomena and the causes of their suffering.
2. Mental formations (sankhara): Due to ignorance, the person forms habitual patterns of criticizing others in an unhelpful or harmful way.
3. Consciousness (viññana): The persons consciousness is conditioned by these mental formations, making them prone to criticizing others.
4. Name and form (nama-rupa): The persons body and mind manifest in a way that is susceptible to unhelpful criticism.
5. The six sense bases (salayatana): The persons sense organs interact with the external world, including other people.
6. Contact (phassa): The person encounters a situation (e.g., seeing someone make a mistake) that triggers unhelpful criticism.
7. Feeling (vedana): The person experiences a sense of displeasure or discomfort as a result of the encounter with the situation.
8. Craving (tanha): The person develops a desire to control or change the situation by criticizing the other person.
9. Clinging (upadana): The persons attachment to their desire to criticize intensifies, leading them to hold onto and escalate their criticism.
10. Becoming (bhava): This clinging to unhelpful criticism reinforces the persons habitual patterns and karmic tendencies.
11. Birth (jati): The persons unhelpful criticism manifests in the form of negative speech or actions directed towards the other person, reinforcing the cycle of mental formations and karmic consequences.
12. Old age and death (jara-marana): Unaddressed unhelpful criticism can lead to detrimental consequences for both the criticized person and the criticizer, perpetuating negative cycles of suffering.
In this example, we can see how the Twelve Nidanas apply to the arising and perpetuation of unhelpful criticism. By understanding the interconnected nature of reality and recognizing the interdependence of the Twelve Links, a person can cultivate mindfulness and work towards breaking the cycle of unhelpful criticism, ultimately leading to greater peace, understanding, and compassion.

How to break cycle at each point:

To break the cycle of unhelpful criticism, we can apply mindfulness and wisdom at multiple points in the chain:

1. Ignorance (avijja): We can cultivate awareness and understanding of our own emotional responses and the impact of our words on others through reflection and mindfulness practices.

2. Mental formations (sankhara): By developing positive mental habits and avoiding negative patterns, we can diminish our tendency to react with criticism towards others.

3. Consciousness (viññana): Through mindfulness practice, we can become more aware of our own cognitive biases and begin to recognize and counteract them.

4. Name and form (nama-rupa): We can work towards avoiding negative or critical perceptions of ourselves and others, cultivating a more balanced and compassionate outlook.

5. The six sense bases (salayatana): By cultivating mindfulness of our senses and mental faculties, we can become more aware of how our biases and patterns of reactivity affect our perceptions of the world around us.

6. Contact (phassa): Through mindfulness practice, we can learn to recognize and investigate our emotional responses to various stimuli, developing a more skillful and compassionate approach to them.

7. Feeling (vedana): By developing equanimity and acceptance towards our feelings, we can reduce our attachment to pleasant feelings and aversion towards unpleasant ones.

8. Craving (tanha): By practicing renunciation and reducing our attachment and aversion to objects of craving, we can weaken our desire to control or change situations through criticism.

9. Clinging (upadana): By practicing non-attachment and recognizing the impermanence of all phenomena, we can reduce our tendency to cling and hold on to our karmic tendencies.

10. Becoming (bhava): By cultivating positive intentions and actions, we can redirect our habitual patterns towards more skillful and wholesome habits.

11. Birth (jati): By avoiding unhelpful speech and actions towards others, we can reduce the harmful impact of our own unskillful behaviors.

12. Old age and death (jara-marana): By breaking the cycle of unhelpful criticism and cultivating positive habits and intentions, we can reduce suffering and promote well-being for ourselves and others.

Conclusion

Unhelpful criticism can lead to suffering for both the criticized person and the criticizer, perpetuating negative cycles. By applying the teachings of the Twelve Nidanas of dependent origination, we can see how unhelpful criticism arises and perpetuates, and cultivate mindfulness and compassion to break the cycle. Through developing positive mental habits and intentions, reducing our attachment and aversion, and redirecting habits towards more skillful and wholesome behaviors, we can promote well-being and reduce suffering for ourselves and others.

Submit A Comment